How long is a day, really?
How long is a day, really?
A popular myth says a day lasts as long as the Earth takes to turn once on its axis. We will show that it does not.
Imagine it is noon
You are standing on the Earth and it is noon: the Sun is due south, at its highest point of the day. Where will the Sun be in the sky when the Earth has finished one turn on its axis?
The Earth turns and moves on at the same time
The Earth does not only spin on its axis, it also orbits the Sun. During one turn it moves a little way along its orbit. If a day lasted just one turn, the next day the Sun would not be due south at noon, but a bit off to the side.
And after a quarter of a year?
After a quarter of a year the difference would be much bigger. If clocks followed the turns, they would say 12:00 while the Sun was only just rising. So does the Earth really turn on its axis in 24 hours?
The Earth has to turn a little further
Here on Earth we do not care how long the Earth takes to turn on its axis. We measure a day from noon to noon: until the Sun is due south again. So after one turn on its axis, we let the Earth turn a little further.
How far does the Earth move on in a day?
A year has 365 days and a circle has 360°. So in one day the Earth covers about 1° of its orbit, and it has to turn that same angle further.
That extra turn takes 4 minutes
The Earth has moved on by 1°, so we have to turn it another 1°. That is one 360th of a turn: a day has 24 × 60 = 1,440 minutes, and one 360th of that is 4 minutes. Only then is the Sun due south again, just as it was at noon yesterday.
The sidereal day
One turn on the axis takes a sidereal day. It lasts 23 hours and 56 minutes. Compared with the distant stars, the Earth has hardly moved in that time, so after one sidereal day you see every constellation in the same place in the sky.
The solar day
When we let the Earth turn on until the Sun is due south again, a solar day has passed. It lasts 24 hours on average, and our clocks follow it. So when we talk about days, we usually mean solar days.
See for yourself
A sidereal day is 4 minutes shorter, so every star rises 4 minutes earlier each day. After a month that is already 2 hours, after half a year 12. That is why Orion is in the evening sky in winter, but in summer rises and sets during the day.
Note where a bright star is at 10 pm tonight, then look there again a week later at the same time. It will have moved a bit further west.
How many times does the Earth turn in a year?
A year has 365 solar days. But a sidereal day is 4 minutes shorter, so one more of them fits into a year: 366. So in a year the Earth turns on its axis 366 times.
So how long is a day?
It depends on what we measure it against. Relative to the stars, the Earth turns in 23 hours and 56 minutes. For the Sun to be back in the same place, the Earth has to turn a little further, so a solar day lasts 24 hours.