Stories

Why do we still see the Sun after it has set?

When you see the Sun setting, it has already set

You watch the Sun’s disc touch the horizon. In reality, though, it has already set completely. What you see is just an optical illusion. How is that possible?

It has to do with refraction

Put a straw in a cup of water and look at the surface from above, at an angle. Under the water the straw looks broken – as if bent up towards the surface. In reality, it is still straight.

Refraction

When light passes into another substance, it changes speed. In water it travels about a quarter slower than in air. When it enters at an angle, it changes direction too – this is called refraction. In oil, light slows down even more, so the straw would look more broken.

How one ray bends

A ray travels straight through the air. As soon as it enters the water at an angle, it bends at the surface and carries on in a different direction.

Light from space

Light from the Sun crosses empty space for 8 minutes and 20 seconds. Then it enters our atmosphere. Air slows light down too, though only slightly – so the ray bends, just as with the straw in water.

We see the Sun higher

The bent ray reaches the eye at a slightly steeper angle from above. But the eye cannot tell that it bent on the way, so we see the Sun higher in the sky than it really is.

Try it underwater

Next time you are in a calm swimming pool and the Sun is low, dive down and look up at the sky from under the surface. You will see the Sun higher than when you poke your head out of the water: at the surface, its light is refracted once more. Just never look straight at the Sun, even underwater.

The more slanted, the more it bends

When the Sun is directly overhead, light comes straight down and does not bend at all. The lower the Sun, the more obliquely light enters the atmosphere and the more it bends. It bends most at the horizon, morning and evening: there it lifts the Sun by about 0.6°, a little more than the Sun’s own width.

That is why we see the Sun after it has set

When the disc touches the horizon, the real Sun is already completely below it. But its light bends in the atmosphere over the horizon and reaches us, so we can still see it for a while.

The day is longer than it should be

The same happens in the morning: we see the Sun before it has really risen. So every day we get a few extra minutes of light. That is why at the equinox the day is not exactly 12 hours long, but a few minutes more.

So?

The setting Sun you see is just an image. The atmosphere bends sunlight the way water bends light from a straw, so you see the Sun for a few minutes after it has really set.